Beware of the "Projection Bias" : it has you hiring an army of clones
10. 2. 2020
2 min.
Our cognitive biaises have a huge impact on the decisions that shape human resources. With this series, we aim to provide short and insightful articles to help you identify the biases, understand how they affect HR, and what to do to address them.Today, discover the “projection bias.”
What is it?
No matter what information we receive, we will interpret it in a way that matches what’s already familiar to us. The projection bias refers to our tendency to project current preferences into the future as if future tastes will always be the same as current ones. But we also tend to project our own preferences—opinions, values, and tastes—onto other people. We see ourselves in others. It is linked to another bias known as the confirmation bias, the tendency we have to search for, interpret, favour, and recall information in a way that reaffirms our prior beliefs and hypotheses.
Our self-centredness leads to evaluate other people’s behaviour based on our own behaviour. We overestimate the extent to which other people agree with us. That’s sometimes referred to as the false-consensus effect, a bias whereby people tend to overestimate the extent to which their own opinions, beliefs, preferences, values and habits are typical. The effect occurs in groups when a consensus seems to have emerged: people from the group tend to believe everybody (even outside the group) agrees with them.
There are psychological and anthropological explanations for this bias. Humans have a profound desire to conform to the group, to be loved by others and to belong. The bias contributes to higher self-esteem. It is very common in groups that feel representative of the overall population and that are very visible in the media. But even in minority groups (like religious fundamentalist groups, for example), people tend to overestimate the number of other people who share their world vision. When you are faced with somebody who thinks differently, you see him/her as “flawed”, i.e. a non-representative anomaly.
In general, the bias leads us to base our decisions on too little information and to use current, personal experience and knowledge to make generalisations about others (and our future selves).
What does it mean for human resources?
In terms of recruitment, projection bias, confirmation bias and false-consensus bias reinforce homogeneity. These biases make it harder to have ethnic, cultural, or gender diversity in an organisation. That’s how the “army of clones” typical of some companies can be accounted for.
Recruiters who aren’t cautious enough will unconsciously favour the candidates they can identify with, simply because they share a hobby, an opinion or a lifestyle choice. In other words, they will let themselves be seduced by a candidate for reasons that are unrelated to that candidate’s ability to do the job.
How can it be overcome?
It is critical to rely on “structured” interviews, i.e. to ask every candidate the exact same questions so as not to let one common characteristic dominate the interview. It is also important to learn to ask open-ended questions. To find out more on the subject, read our must-read article about Who: The A Method for Hiring by Geoff Smart and Randy Street. Collegiate recruitment decisions, made by a diverse group of people (men and women of different ages and backgrounds) will make it easier to promote diversity and neutralise each recruiter’s individual biases. Conversely, if the group of decision-makers is homogeneous then the biases will be reinforced rather than neutralised.
Další inspirace: Laetitia Vitaud
Future of work author and speaker
How women over 50 are reinventing their careers and the future of work
Women in their 20s struggle to be taken seriously, while middle-aged women battle discrimination... So how are women over 50 reinventing the wheel?
02. 4. 2024
Ego depletion: The more decisions you make, the worse they become!
Digital demands and information overload are at an all-time high, making decision fatigue a critical challenge impacting productivity and well-being.
27. 3. 2024
Let's stop looking down on ‘good students’ at work
Much like the adjective “kind”, calling someone a “good student” in the workplace is almost always pejorative, but why?
22. 2. 2024
Is a world without work (really) possible?
Our Lab expert Laetitia Vitaud explains why she doesn’t believe in a future of unemployment and leisure.
19. 2. 2024
Working time: It’s not just a question of how long you spend
If we look back to the works of the ancient Greeks, we begin to see that time isn’t just about “duration.” Intrigued?
08. 1. 2024
Uvnitř džungle: HR newsletter
Studie, události, odborné analýzy, řešení... Každé dva týdny ve vaší poštovní schránce.
Jste hrdí na vaši firemní kulturu?
Poskytněte jí viditelnost, kterou si zaslouží.
Zjistěte více o tom, jak propagovat firemní kulturu.